"All claims, guarantees and product specifications are provided by the manufacturer or vendor.Toilet Tricks cannot be held responsible for these claims, guarantees or specifications" (ad) “As An Amazon Associate, I Earn From Qualifying Purchases.” (Paid Link)
When it comes to upgrading or building a new bathroom, choosing the right toilet can make all the difference. Two popular names that homeowners and contractors often debate between are Gerber and Kohler. While both have strong reputations, their differences in design, quality, availability, and pricing can lead you to favour one over the other depending on your needs. In this in-depth comparison, we’ll break down the key aspects of Gerber toilets vs. Kohler—from build quality and design to pricing and installation feedback—so you can make an informed decision.
| Feature | Gerber Toilets | Kohler Toilets |
|---|---|---|
| Build Quality | Budget-friendly, solid but basic | Premium build with advanced engineering |
| Availability | Plumbing supply stores mainly | Big box stores (Home Depot, Lowe’s) |
| Parts Replacement | May vary by model | Widely available and standardized |
| Price | More affordable overall | Slightly more expensive |
| Design and Aesthetics | Traditional designs | Modern, sleek options available |
| Performance | Reliable flushing | Innovative flush technologies |
| Installation Ease | Straightforward with plumber | DIY-friendly with guides |
| Recommended Models | Gerber Viper, Avalanche | Kohler Cimarron, Wellworth |
Gerber toilets are known for offering solid performance at a competitive price. They’re often selected for commercial settings or multi-unit buildings because of their value and durability. However, many users note that Gerber focuses on function more than form—so the design is often basic.
On the other hand, Kohler toilets are associated with a higher-end bathroom experience. Their toilets are often heavier due to more premium materials, and their finishes tend to be sleeker. Reviewers often mention Kohler’s long-lasting performance and durability, especially in models like the Kohler Cimarron.
Reddit Feedback: One user mentioned Gerber as the standard choice for installing toilets across 24 apartment units, citing solid reliability.
Many users installing Gerber toilets rely on professional plumbers, especially in larger setups. It’s often the go-to brand for contractors outfitting multiple units, making it familiar among trade professionals.
Kohler, by contrast, is more DIY-friendly. With wide availability in major retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s, Kohler toilets are often picked up by homeowners doing their own renovations. Installation instructions are straightforward, and parts are easier to find when troubleshooting.
User Insight: One Redditor pointed out that their plumber refused to install big-box toilets due to quality concerns, preferring supplier-bought versions—even among the same SKU.
When it comes to flushing power, both brands perform well, but Kohler has the edge with its advanced flushing systems like AquaPiston. This system allows water to enter the bowl from all sides, increasing efficiency and minimizing clogs.
Gerber toilets use standard siphon jet technology. While effective, it doesn’t offer the same water-saving innovations or power as Kohler’s newer models.
Helpful Tip: A user noted they had no complaints with Kohler’s flushing performance and easily fixed a leak with Amazon-ordered parts.
This is where Gerber shines—the brand is positioned as a budget-conscious option. It offers good performance for a lower cost, making it a smart pick for bulk installations or landlord-managed properties.
Kohler comes at a higher price point, but with that comes higher-quality finishes, longer lifespan, and modern design.
Reddit Quote: “Gerber is a good model cheaper of the two, but Kohler’s parts are easier to find and last longer.”
Many homeowners run into part issues over time. This is where Kohler outperforms Gerber. Replacement parts for Kohler are easy to find online or in-store. Additionally, many Kohler models use standardized components that don’t vary drastically by vendor.
Gerber parts are often exclusive to plumbing suppliers, making them harder to obtain for DIY repairs.
User Tip: “I had to buy Kohler-specific parts to fix a leak. Got them on Amazon quickly.”
This was a major debate in the Reddit thread. The consensus:
One user even mentioned their plumber refused to install Home Depot-purchased toilets due to quality control issues.
Insight: “Plumbing vendors tend to get better quality products with a much lower chance of defects.”
Fan Favorite: Kohler Cimarron was mentioned multiple times as a standout model.
Let’s imagine you’re redoing a single bathroom in your own home.
This aligns with one Redditor’s experience installing 24 Gerber elongated 2-piece units for an apartment complex.
Gerber toilets are reliable, especially for basic needs, but Kohler typically offers better long-term durability with premium materials.
Parts are available, but usually through plumbing supply stores, not big-box retailers.
Yes. Many professionals agree that supply stores carry better-quality variants, even for the same toilet models.
For most users, Kohler Cimarron or Wellworth models provide excellent performance and reliability.
Not at all. They’re often praised for their clear instructions and compatibility with DIY installation.
Both Gerber and Kohler have their place in the toilet market. Gerber is a solid, budget-friendly option for basic installs, multi-unit housing, or cost-conscious consumers. Kohler, however, stands out for performance, style, and ease of maintenance.
If you’re building a luxury bathroom or just want a toilet you won’t have to think about for 10 years, go with Kohler. If you’re equipping 20 rental bathrooms on a tight budget, Gerber will get the job done.
Have you installed a Gerber or Kohler toilet recently? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let us know which one worked best for you!